phone
Email
Online Inquiry
Verification code

Choosing the Right Surfactant for Your Herbicide: Non-Ionic vs. Ionic

What Are Surfactants and Why Are They Important for Herbicides?

Definition and Role of Surfactants in Herbicide Formulations

Surfactants are chemicals that decrease the surface tension of liquids dramatically. Surfactants are common adjuvants to herbicides in formulations for improved performance. Surfactants increase the wettability of water so herbicides stick better to plant leaves, and are more effective against weeds.

How Surfactants Enhance Herbicide Performance

  • Wetting: Spreads herbicide uniformly on plant leaves, no slide-off.
  • Dispersing: Gives the herbicide more even distribution in the spray, and has a better chance of reaching the plant.
  • Penetrating: Allows the herbicide to pass through the plant's waxy cuticle into the plant body.
  • Sticking: Stables the herbicide to the surface of the plants longer for greater effectiveness.

Key Benefits of Using Surfactants in Herbicide Applications

  • Enhanced Herbicide Efficiency: Wetting, dispersing, and penetrating properties of herbicides are enhanced by surfactants, which enable them to hit more effectively with plants.
  • Reduced Chemical Usage: Because surfactants enhance the herbicide's absorption, a smaller amount of herbicide can be required, reducing environmental impact.
  • Protection of Non-Target Plants: Some surfactants are relatively safe for non-target plants like vegetables and fruits, so you can minimize damage to these plants.
  • Reduced Drift and Volatility: Surfactants enhance spray adsorption and stability by suppressing herbicide drift and volatility to make the application more accurate.

Pesticide dissolution makes surfactant micelles hydrophobicPesticide dissolution makes surfactant micelles more hydrophobic

Surfactants are essential for herbicides because they not only make herbicides effective but also help save the environment. The right type of surfactant (e.g., nonionic vs cationic) will depend on the herbicide formulation and use case. Nonionic surfactants are commonly used in agriculture and landscaping because they're broad compatible and less toxic.

How Do Surfactants Work in Herbicide Formulations?

Basic Principles of Surfactant Action

Surfactants act by weakening the surface tension of water so that droplets of spray are more likely to permeate and coat plant leaves. The loss of surface tension makes the spray more wettable and dispersed, thus reducing the distance and length of time the herbicide contacts the plant.

Surfactants Work in Herbicide FormulationsImprove pesticide bioavailability and minimize environmental risk by surfactants

The Role of Surfactants in Droplet Size and Spray Retention

Surfactants also minimize rebound and evaporation so that the droplets get distributed more evenly on the plant surface. This is good for spray uniformity and also longer lasting on the leaves. Surfactants can also make the spray performance better by modifying the droplet shape and size to allow them to pass through the capillary systems of the leaves.

Impact on Herbicide Efficacy and Plant Absorption

Surfactants improve the performance of herbicides by increasing the amount of contact of the herbicide on the surface of the plant, allowing it to permeate and absorb better. They're solvents that make herbicides bleed through the waxy skin of the plant and be more biologically active and effective. But the action of surfactants is also determined by their chemical composition and amount. Too much can result in a thin film that can diminish the residual herbicide.

Surfactants contribute to the herbicide formulations by reducing surface tension, increasing wettability and coverage, decreasing the size of droplets and spray time, and increasing the herbicide's permeability and absorption, all of which will greatly enhance herbicide performance.

What Are Non-Ionic Surfactants?

Definition and Characteristics of Non-Ionic Surfactants

Non-ionic surfactants are chargeless (they do not ionize in water, nor do they change the pH of the solution). Their hydrophilic part consists mostly of polyethylene glycol chains, and their hydrophobic portion contains saturated or unsaturated fatty acids, fatty alcohols or fatty oils. Non-ionic surfactants, being charge-free, are irritant and toxic less, so can be used in the biomedical and food markets. They are also stable in hard water and not easily influenced by calcium and magnesium ions.

Common Examples

Common non-ionic surfactants include polyethylene glycol esters (such as polyethylene glycol fatty acid esters), alkylphenol ethoxylates (such as nonylphenol ethoxylates), and fatty alcohol ethoxylates. These compounds are widely used in areas such as cleaners, emulsifiers, and solubilizers.

Advantages of Non-Ionic Surfactants in Herbicide Applications

  • Stability in Hard Water

Non-ionic surfactants don't easily react to calcium and magnesium ions in hard water, so they are resilient in hard water.

  • Compatibility with Other Chemicals

Non-ionic surfactants can be used with different types of cationic and anionic surfactants and other chemicals which makes them ideal for mixed solutions.

Non-ionic surfactants are extensively used in agriculture, industry and cosmetics because of their chemical characteristics and wider use potential.

How Do Non-Ionic Surfactants Affect Herbicide Performance?

Enhancing Herbicide Penetration and Uptake

Non-ionic surfactants help herbicides break through cuticles in the plant leaf wax by dispersing water's surface tension. This helps the herbicide penetrate the plant more effectively and get absorbed faster. Non-ionic surfactants, for instance, can remove the waxy coat on leaves to help the herbicide get into the guts. Additionally, non-ionic surfactants can open up the area between spray drops and the leaves, increasing permeability of the herbicide.

Surfactant for enhancing herbicide penetration and uptakeSurfactant enhancing herbicide penetration and uptake

Reducing Drift and Improving Droplet Retention

Non-ionic surfactants can help keep spray droplets more concentrated and longer linger on plants. Because they release the surface tension of the spray droplets, decreasing the probability of dropping and keeping the droplets on the plant surface longer, increasing the uniformity and efficiency of herbicide coverage. Non-ionic surfactants also slow down the evaporation of the spray droplets, increasing the herbicide's efficiency.

Case Studies or Examples of Non-Ionic Surfactants in Use

More practically, non-ionic surfactants are widely used in agriculture and landscaping for improving the efficacy of herbicides. In herbicide applications on US prairies and pastures, for instance, non-ionic surfactants optimise the absorption and efficacy of herbicides. In aquatic plants, non-ionic surfactants can also be used to maximize herbicide control on aquatic plants. A couple of researches have also demonstrated that non-ionic surfactants are highly effective when used in combination with other components (eg, silicone oils).

What Are Ionic Surfactants?

Definition and Classification of Ionic Surfactants

Ionic surfactants are surfactants that, when in solution, break down into charged ions. Depending on the charge-balancing effect of their molecular arrangement, ionic surfactants further divided into anionic, cationic and amphoteric (or zwitterionic).

  • Anionic Surfactants

These surfactants are negative after dissociation in water. Typical anionic surfactants are sulfates, sulfonates and carboxylates. These materials are often long-chain carbon chains and commonly present in soaps, detergents and cleaners.

  • Cationic Surfactants

These surfactants have a positive charge after they are dissociated in water. Almost all cationic surfactants contain a positively charged nitrogen atom (compact examples are quaternary ammonium salts and amine salts).

  • Amphoteric Surfactants

Depending on environment pH, these surfactants are anionic or cationic. Typically, they are amphipathic, that is, with both hydrophilic and lipophilic parts.

Properties and Common Examples of Each Type

Type of SurfactantPropertiesExamples
Anionic SurfactantsHigh foaming, used as emulsifiers and dispersants in cleanersSodium dodecylbenzenesulfonate (SDBS), fat acid salts, alkyl sulfates, etc.
Cationic SurfactantsUsually antimicrobial, used in disinfectants and sterilizing products; cationic in acidic conditions, anionic in alkaline conditionsBenzalkonium chloride (BZK), cetyltrimethylammonium bromide, etc.
Amphoteric SurfactantsChange charge depending on pH; effective in emulsification, solubilization, and wettingLecithin, betaine compounds, etc.

Ionic surfactants are charge-sensitive and multifunctional, so they can be found in a host of industrial and personal use cases, from cleaning agents to medicines and cosmetics.

How Do Ionic Surfactants Impact Herbicide Efficacy?

Mechanisms of Action for Anionic and Cationic Surfactants

  • Anionic Surfactants

Anionic surfactants are negatively charged and ionize in water to make anions. They aid herbicide absorption by decreasing the surface tension of water, allowing the herbicide to be easily absorbed and spread on the plant surface. Contact herbicides are often formulated with anionic surfactants, which act directly on the plant surface instead of passing into the plant system. But because of their negative charge, anionic surfactants are rarely used together with cationic surfactants, as they would precipitate in water, becoming useless.

  • Cationic Surfactants

Cationic surfactants are positive charge that ionizes in water which cations. They are more surface soluble, and also less solvent soluble which means they can be able to better adhere to plants, and they are able to penetrate the wax layer of the plant. This is why cationic surfactants can improve the cationic adhesion and permeability of the herbicide. But the chemical is stronger and less used for agriculture.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Ionic Surfactants

  • Anionic Surfactants

Advantages: Anionic surfactants will be effective in moistening and spreading herbicides so that they will spread more uniformly over plant surfaces and thus be better absorbed and effective. And they keep herbicides from getting washed away by rain or irrigation, optimizing herbicidal efficacy.

Disadvantages: With anionic surfactants in conjunction, they precipitate and detract from herbicidal action. Also some anionic surfactants can be toxic, so be careful with your choice.

  • Cationic Surfactants

Advantages: Cationic surfactants are extremely adherent and permeable, and can be a means to prolong herbicides' time on plant surfaces and to make them penetrate deeper into plant wax. Which makes them, in some situations, more effective.

Disadvantages: Because of their toxicity and potential environmental effects, cationic surfactants are not typically approved for use in herbicide formulations. They can also precipitate when combined with anionic surfactants, and they lose functionality.

Potential Interactions with Herbicides and Other Chemicals

  • Interactions with Herbicides

Ionic surfactants can make herbicides much more absorbed and effective. Anionic surfactants, for instance, make water easier to absorb into the plant's tissue, by reducing its surface tension. But in its incorrect use, over-addition or accidental admixture with other non-compatibility chemicals could diminish herbicidal activity or produce unwanted side effects.

  • Interactions with Other Chemicals

Ionic surfactants can also react with other substances in herbicides or in the environment. For example, some cationic surfactants react with calcium and magnesium ions in hard water to create precipitates that can interfere with herbicide action.

The ionic surfactants provide an essential herbicidal benefit, though these must be used with care so as not to cause harm or pollution.

How to Choose the Right Surfactant for Your Herbicide?

Factors to Consider

  • Type of Herbicide

Depending on the herbicide, you might need different surfactants to make them work better. For instance, some herbicides may require cationic or anionic surfactants and others nonionic.

  • Target Plant Species

There are many different herbicide sensitivity of plants, therefore a surfactant which is suitable for that particular plant can have a higher herbicidal action. Some surfactants will also work better against particular types of weeds, for example.

  • Environmental Conditions

Surfactant selection can also be influenced by environmental factors like water hardness, pH, etc. In the case of certain surfactants, for instance, use in hard water can precipitate or cause less effectiveness.

Matching Surfactant Properties to Herbicide Needs

  • When to Use Non-Ionic vs. Ionic Surfactants

Non-Ionic Surfactants: Non-ionic surfactants are generally safe and a general choice, suitable for most applications where there is a concern not to impact non-target plants. Non-ionic surfactants do not change the pH of the herbicide and are therefore usually a good choice.

Ionic Surfactants: The surface activity and solubility of cationic and anionic surfactants are higher but are more reactive to plants or environments. Therefore, they must be properly vetted before being applied.

  • Practical Tips for Selecting the Best Surfactant

Read Product Labels: Before choosing and using a surfactant, be sure to check the product label to get the proper concentration and usage guidelines. This means that the surfactant you use will work perfectly well to boost the herbicide performance.

Test and Adjust: Small-scale trials are recommended before a larger scale application to make sure that the chosen surfactant does not cause any negative effects on crops or the environment. Modify surfactant concentration and form according to test results.

Consider Environmental Factors: Select a surfactant based on local climate, soil type, and water hardness. A low-concentration non-ionic surfactant, for instance, could work better in hard water.

With such considerations and selection of the right surfactant depending on the specific application requirements, herbicide performance can be enhanced with little risk of toxicity to the environment or untarget plants.

What Are the Best Practices for Using Surfactants in Herbicide Applications?

Guidelines for Mixing and Application

  • It's common to add surfactants as adjuvants to herbicides to make them more effective. Mix according to product label and use the correct concentration/ratio. The recommendation is for nonionic surfactants (Citowett Plus, Ag Surf II, Agral 90, etc.) 0.2 l/100 litres of spray solution.
  • Mix with quality water and use the ready herbicide solution soon after it has been prepared to prevent loss of effectiveness from water quality problems (alkalinity or hardness).
  • For certain special herbicides, if a pre-mixed surfactant is not listed on the label, it should be used before application.

Safety Considerations and Environmental Impact

  • Whenever using surfactants you have to consider the impact they may have on the environment. Surfactants can be harmful to aquatic life, so only surfactants designed for aquatic use should be chosen when applying herbicides in the vicinity of water or wetlands.
  • Surfactants may make pesticides more mobile in the soil and therefore more susceptible to running off pesticides into bodies of water. But this is usually not a great influence under ordinary circumstances since soils are low in surfactants.
  • With the addition of surfactants, the amount of herbicide used will be reduced and this will result in less pollution.

Troubleshooting Common Issues with Surfactants

  • When herbicide is poor, that might be because the surfactant was of the wrong type or concentration. There are many surfactants (eg, non-ionic, cationic, anionic) that can penetrate plant tissues, and you need to select the appropriate one for the application.
  • During application, clean any apparatus (sprayer) to prevent cross-contamination. It also has to be selected at the right time for application depending on weather, geography, and environment.
  • If herbicides cannot be resisted on plant leaves, the surfactant type or concentration might need to be modified to increase the adhesion and permeability.

Following these best practices, herbicides using surfactants can have the greatest possible efficiency with the least amount of harmful impact on the environment.

How to Evaluate Surfactant Performance in the Field?

Methods for Testing Surfactant Efficacy

  • Surface Tension Testing: This is one of the basic tests for surfactant performance. It evaluates the effect of surfactants through the surface tension of the solution when exposed to air. Drop volume, ring and capillary are common test methods.
  • Wetting Time Method: For measuring the ability of surfactants to wet solid surfaces, this method measures performance by time needed to wet.
  • Permeability Method: Determines surfactant penetration into a medium, corresponding to their diffusion in different conditions.
  • Dynamic Surface Tension Testing: Represents dynamic surfactant behavior at interfaces. It is usually done by the large bubble pressure or the drop weight technique.

Key Metrics to Monitor

  • Coverage: The effectiveness of the surfactant is evaluated by measuring its coverage over the target surface. This can be achieved by optical measurement techniques or direct observation.
  • Permeability: Generally, the penetration ability of the surfactant is measured via permeability.
  • Drift Reduction: In agricultural applications, surfactants can improve pesticide adhesion and minimize drift, therefore making use of pesticides more efficient.

Real-World Examples and Case Studies

  • In agriculture, studies indicate that two surfactants act together in a way that enhances pesticide wettability and stickiness.
  • In oil extraction, a mix of lab and field testing was conducted to assess the effects of cation exchange on recovery of non-aqueous phase liquids, and a "push-pull" test protocol was developed for field-scale testing.

Enhanced Oil Recovery by Injecting Oleic Acid as a SurfactantEnhanced oil recovery by injecting oleic acid as a surfactant into the porous medium

  • In coal dust suppression, different surfactants were tested in static and dynamic testing, and different tests can produce different results.

With such tools and indicators, the effectiveness of surfactants in various application scenarios can be fully analyzed and improved.

References

  1. Hu, X., et al. "Contrasting impacts of mixed nonionic surfactant micelles on plant growth in the delivery of fungicide and herbicide." Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 618 (2022): 78-87.
  2. Bao, Z., et al. "The simple strategy to improve pesticide bioavailability and minimize environmental risk by effective and ecofriendly surfactants." Science of The Total Environment 851 (2022): 158169.
  3. Liu, H., et al. "Foliar penetration enhanced by biosurfactant rhamnolipid." Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces 145 (2016): 548-554.
  4. Mohamed, M. S., et al. "Enhanced oil recovery by injecting oleic acid as a surfactant into the porous medium." Open Journal of Fluid Dynamics 10.01 (2020): 82.

PAGE TOP